On October 19, Scituate's Special Town Meeting approved $3,835,165 in Community Preservation money to turn 44 Jericho Road into Pier 44 Park. According to South Shore News, the motion passed by the required two-thirds on a voice vote, after a resident moved the question. The night's argument was about money and parking spaces. The bigger question of what could go on that 1.1-acre parcel had been settled much earlier. The deed restrictions that came with the town's 2010 purchase decided it would be public open space, and years of flood damage to the old building decided what kind of open space it could be. Seen that way, the park is easier to understand, including the things it won't have.
A purchase that fixed the outcome in 2010
The town's own history of the site starts at the May 2010 Town Meeting. Voters there approved, by a two-thirds vote, using $1.75 million in MBTA mitigation funds to buy the Pier 44 property, on the condition that it be used for noncommercial purposes that provide public access to the waterfront. The town took ownership in June 2010. The property is protected under Article 97, and its deed requires it to be kept for outdoor recreation, public education, harbor access and public enjoyment.
The town's Community Preservation application for the park explains why the deed protects public access so firmly. It says the rest of Scituate Harbor is largely fenced off by private property. That makes Pier 44 one of the few places on the harbor's edge the public can count on reaching. The application also puts the site on the route of the Scituate Harbor Walk.
The same limits came up when the Select Board took up the project on September 22. According to the meeting minutes, board members reminded the room that the land comes with use stipulations, and one member said a parking lot is not an option for it.
From there, the site's history is mostly a story of waiting:
- February 2011. A survey of town departments found the parcel too small and too restricted for government offices. An online survey drew 1,011 responses, most favoring open space or park use.
- April 2011. About 150 people attended a public workshop.
- March 2012. A Phase 1 report called a full park, with the building demolished, one of the more feasible options.
- 2012 to 2021. The project paused while the Public Safety Building, Town Library, Gates Middle School and Senior Center went ahead.
- 2021. A new survey drew 1,013 responses, with park use the top choice at 42.35 percent. That September the Scituate Harbor Advisory Redevelopment Commission, known as SHARC, was created.
- 2022 and 2023. Copley Wolff Design Group was hired, the Metropolitan Area Planning Council awarded a $100,000 preconstruction grant, and the April 2023 Town Meeting approved $300,000 in CPC funding.
- November 2025. The park design reached 90 percent.
Every survey along the way favored a park, and the deed allowed little else. So by the time the article reached the floor last month, the open question was how much park, at what price.
What the water took off the list
The building at Pier 44 is a former restaurant, used lately for function rentals. The town's application says it has sustained repeated flood damage, has generated multiple insurance claims, is not ADA compliant and does not meet current FEMA floodplain standards. Bringing it up to code would mean raising it above base flood elevation, which would in turn require extensive ramps for accessibility. The town rejected rehabilitation as impractical, so the building will be demolished.
The flood zone shaped the new design too. Early plans included a small restroom and comfort station, but the application says rules on building in a flood zone made it impossible to permit. Residents also asked for splash pads, playgrounds, bocce courts, concerts, a beer garden, solar panels, a snack shack, a maritime center and a visitor center. SHARC kept the design simple and centered on passive recreation, citing regulatory concerns and cost.
The 2023 survey drew 1,284 responses. Comparing what those respondents asked for with the approved design shows how the constraints played out:
| What the 2023 survey asked for | What the approved design includes |
|---|---|
| Open lawn | An open lawn at the center, ringed by an ADA-accessible path |
| Boardwalk | A pile-supported boardwalk along the seaward edge |
| Kayak tie-up | A small-boat tie-up at the harbor's edge |
| Restrooms | None, because a building could not be permitted in the flood zone |
| 10 to 14 parking spaces, favored by 968 respondents | About 20 spaces, plus parallel parking on Jericho Road |
The parking row helps explain the debate. The final design has more spaces than survey respondents asked for in 2023, and parking was still the main objection raised against the plan. Public comment at the September 22 Select Board meeting included opposition centered on the loss of overflow parking at Pier 44, according to the minutes. At that meeting, Select Board member Nico Afanasenko said the board is working on the town's parking issues but that this site is not a good place for parking and has additional environmental issues.
The floor fight was about price
With the land's use already fixed, the debate at Town Meeting came down to cost. The case for the park, as South Shore News reported it, started from the deed. Afanasenko told the meeting that the MBTA's deed restrictions allow only public open space and recreation. He said design changes had cut the estimate from $6 million, that a $100,000 grant was already secured, and that the existing building costs taxpayers $30,000 a year in insurance and utilities. He put it this way:
"The only question tonight is whether it's a beautiful park or a patch of dirt."
The Advisory Committee didn't dispute that the site should be a park. Vice Chair Missy Seidel said the committee supports a public waterfront space, but it voted 2-4 against this plan over its cost. She put the town's total investment at just over $7 million: $2.5 million already invested, the $3.8 million request, and an estimated $742,000 to borrow $3 million at 4.5 percent over 10 years. She said a simpler design with more modest paths and plantings would be more fiscally prudent. Another Advisory Committee member, speaking as a resident, said the boardwalk alone costs $1 million.
Other boards lined up behind the project. The Select Board voted 4-1 in favor. The Community Preservation Committee voted unanimously for it and, despite disliking borrowing, described it as the only way to finish a 16-year effort. The Economic Development Commission also voted unanimously in support, saying the park would draw visitors to harbor businesses.
The numbers that will last beyond the vote are these. The approved motion draws $835,165 from undesignated fund balance and authorizes $3 million in borrowing, reduced by any grants received first. Finance Director Nancy Holt said the park debt will take 10 years to repay and will reduce CPC money available for other projects, though at least $1 million a year should remain available. The town administrator said revetment work accounts for about $400,000 of the cost.
What changes on Jericho Road
Under the approved design, the building and the pavement both go. The sidewalk moves off Jericho Road and into the park, which the town describes as a safer walk and which also frees up room for parallel parking along the road. Someone walking the Harbor Walk can continue north or follow a path out to the boardwalk, which the application says looks out over Scituate Harbor and its lighthouse.
Some of the work won't be visible. The site will be regraded to hold more floodwater, and the asphalt will be replaced with permeable surfaces, native plantings and bio-retention areas. Scituate Harbor is currently listed as an impaired waterbody because of fecal coliform contamination. The town expects the project to reduce total suspended solids from the site by 88 percent and total phosphorus loading by 66 percent.
Any parking beyond the roughly 20 spaces in the design would come later. The town administrator told Town Meeting that added parking along Jericho Road would be a separate project. The application points to the stretch of Jericho Road north of the site, next to the boat ramp, as the place for it.
Town staff will run the public bidding for an owner's project manager and a construction contractor. SHARC has committed to coordinating updates so residents can follow construction progress. The commission's outreach summary is posted on the SHARC page on the town website.
I keep a close eye on harbor projects like Pier 44 because they change how this part of town works day to day, from where people walk to where they park. If you live near Jericho Road or the harbor and want to talk through what the park could mean for your street or your plans, Brita Sheehan is glad to sit down with you for a complimentary home consultation.